Categorized | India

Tata Nano – Fizz or Fuzz

Tata’s Nano has created a lot of buzz in the international media. Ratan Tata, chairman of Tata delivered what he had promised – a car for the people at the bottom of the pyramid. Here is what BusinessWeek is saying about the car and its surrounding hoopla.

“If you follow the auto business, the place to be today is New Delhi, where Tata Motors has unveiled its long-awaited $2500 car, the Nano. No doubt the folks at Tata are enjoying their moment in the spotlight, and deservedly so. When Ratan Tata first started talking about the company’s plans to develop an ultra-cheap car, lots of people said there was no way Tata could do it. Today, of course, there’s a huge amount of buzz around the car and the many creative ways Tata engineers found to cut costs. And many other, more established automakers are rushing to come out with inexpensive cars of their own for the developing world.”

Some of the claims made by the company regarding the facts about the car sound dubious. For instance, the company said “Nano passes European emssion standards and is designed to pass international crash test standard”.

However according to a BusinessWeek report, TATA saved money on the manufacturing cost by leaving out $900 worth of emission control equipment that is a mandatory requirement in US, EU and Japan. How can then the car pass European norms of emission.

Tata will also be forgoing standard features such as air bags and support beams that protect passengers in a crash. “It’s safer than putting four people on a scooter, but that’s it,” according to Sandy Munro, president of Troy (Mich.) consulting firm Munro & Associates, which has advised Tata on manufacturing the car.

The answer to whether Tata’s would be providing ABS (Antilock brakes) is also a no brainer.

At best, Nano has a fair chance of being a success in not so tightly regulated markets like south Asia, Africa etc. But even then can Nano take on the second hand cars market.

    6 Responses to “Tata Nano – Fizz or Fuzz”

    1. Nick says:

      As per the statistics from Economis, about 1,800 people die on Delhi’s roads each year, perhaps one-third of them on two-wheelers. Only 5% die in cars. Tata’s project may pose risks for investors, but it promises unaccustomed safety for customers.

      Nano will defn have a positive effect at least in one segment if the car becomes a success.

    2. suhail says:

      well tata nano is for asain countries n tata dint have any plans for promoting it to US or UK….
      it for a “comman man” n countries like india,phil n africa and abt safety with air bags people who want it can always add those features in it

    3. SM says:

      There is a lot of FUD being put out by competitors (especially in India) who are terrified by the Nano – particularly the two wheeler manufaxcturers and Maruti Suzuki who currently make the worlds cheapest car at twice the price. Businessweek is an Indian publication by the way, and the likes of Bajaj, Hero-Honda, and Maruti-Suzuki must be important advertisers.

      Basically the Nano has been under tight wraps until last week, and almost nothing was known about it. Tata says that they have tested the Nano and that it is complies with international crash test standards and Euro IV emission standards (same as Bharat III Indian emission standards)because they have actually tested it.

      Yet you get a whole load of pundits who have just crawled out of the woodwork, with no access to any the Nano or to any data about it other than what other pundits have been saying for the pasy year, who profess to know that it won’t pass crash tests, that it won’t comply with international standards. Go figure!


    1. […] the question being asked in Wired. We had earlier profiled the world’s cheapest car by Indian conglomerate, Tata’s and had raised some questions […]

    Leave a Reply

    You must be logged in to post a comment.